(SNN) - Recently 16-year-old Texas teen Ethan Couch pleaded guilty to driving drunk and killing four people and injuring others, including paralyzing one of his passengers. However, he's not going to jail. Because his parents are wealthy his defense was that he suffered from "affluenza" (aka being a spoiled little rich boy), as if it were some disorder. His father is described as "holding hostages" rather than having relationships, and his mother is described as "indulgent." But can't the same be said of many non-wealthy troubled teen families?
His punishment? Two years in a luxury rehabilitation center for wealthy troubled teens, and ten years probation. You can read about it here and here.
Detractors are saying it's not justice and are comparing Couch's sentence to that of non-wealthy teens that get into the same kind of trouble. In addition, poorer teens in the prison system have records that can follow them for life.
Proponents are saying under the current Texas law, had Couch received the maximum sentence, he would be eligible for parole two years into his 20-year sentence. With the sentence he received he will not do hard time but he will be under threat of the justice system for 10 years, during which time he could be sent to prison if he messes up.
Another factor in teen crime, that has yet to be mentioned, is the development of the brain. According to scientists, the human brain is not fully matured until the early 20s. (You can read about teen brain development here and here.) So can we really hold ANY teen responsible for their behavior? What about adults with brain trauma? Can we hold them responsible for their actions? In light of the number of Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI) in veterans of the Iraq and Afghanistan theatres, perhaps this is a discussion that needs to be held nationally.
The sentence Couch received may be a just one, but is it just when rich kids get the soft treatment and poor kids get the harsher? Shouldn't all teens get comparable justice? Shouldn't all citizens get comparable justice for comparable crimes?
I'd like to believe there is equal justice in the world, especially in the American legal system, but the truth is life and justice is full of human gatekeepers who have all the flaws and biases of any human. Often things are made harder or easier based on whether you're liked, whether you can find common ground with the gatekeeper, whether you have the money or influence to open gates, whether prejudice slams the gate shut....
In the case of Couch, the gatekeeper judge chose to go easier on him than she might have chosen to do, had Couch been from a poorer class. Which leads me to confirm an idea I've long suspected: that you get as much justice in America as you can afford to buy.
Maye Ralston is an opinion columnist for The Sage News and contributes to Writing Heartland blog and the Midwest Writers Workshop blog in addition to volunteering with the MWW Planning Committee.
Photo: Some rights reserved by jayRaz flickr photostream, The Sage nor this article endorsed.
More Opinion News
-
Cork and the Geez Talk Oscars
Monday, February 27, 2017
The Old Coot & the Geezer analyze what went wrong and what went right at the Academy Awards this year, review the show, and recommend who should host next year. The duo are America's most respected fuddy-duddy film ...
-
Cork and the Geez Dish on the Golden Globes
Tuesday, January 24, 2017
(SNN) The Old Coot and the Geezer, affected no doubt by the rainy weather in Southern California turn grumpy as they analyze the Golden Globes and show what they mean--mostly good food for the media. Will Hollywood ...
-
Revisiting "Two-a-Days" with One Small Difference
Thursday, October 06, 2016
(SNN) For four years of high school and one in college, I would spend a couple of weeks during the dog days of August involved in what was known as "Two-a-days." Those, as any current or former football player ...
-
Coping with the Wobblies
Sunday, September 18, 2016
(SNN) Belonging to an elite group is only fun if it was one you aspired to, like giving a hundred speeches and becoming a Distinguished Toastmaster. During that time I would get the “wobblies” almost weekly. “What’s ...
-
Experimental Turkeys & Murphy's Law
Friday, September 16, 2016
(SNN) It is a paradox of science that before any breakthrough there is often a f’ed-up earlier stage. Out of this f’ed-stage have come some turkeys – turkeys that crossed the road to find something of value on the ...
-
Adventures in Eating
Sunday, August 21, 2016
(SNN) Some food combinations reside in the collective unconscious – and then there are those that shouldn’t exist at all. That special is a lottery. Visible from my apartment is a restaurant that has been struggling ...
-
No More Miscarriage Taboo
Friday, June 24, 2016
(SNN) I got a tattoo recently to honor the life and death of my daughter. The potential of her. The possibility of her. The scarred grief of her that tore up my heart. The fact that she was not born alive did not ...
-
Since the Pulse Stopped
Tuesday, June 21, 2016
Since 'the Pulse stopped,' I've been thinking a few things. (SNN) The other day 49 human beings were murdered, and 53 more were injured in an attempt to murder them, simply for being in a "Gay" nightclub called ...
-
Fall Down, Go Boom
Tuesday, March 22, 2016
(SNN) My doctor has asked me to not fall down. I’ve attempted to honor his request, but it's easier said than done. Staying upright cannot be taken for granted if, like me, you own a fused ankle, Silly Putty knee ...
-
Character Actors: Not Just In It to Win It
Friday, January 29, 2016
(SNN) The death this week of actor Abe Vigoda at 94 reminds us that there are degrees of success of Hollywood, that fame can come after thirty years of toiling in obscurity, and that a great actor is a great actor ...