(SNN) - Controversy arose this week over the Michael Dunn case, often referred to as the "Florida loud music killing case." Briefly, Dunn, a White male, parked next to an SUV in which some Black teenagers sat listening to loud music, described by Dunn as "rap crap" and "thug" music. A disagreement ensued and Dunn, fired a 9-millimeter legal handgun into the SUV and continued firing as the SUV left. The gunfire struck Jordan Davis, one of the SUV's passengers, three times causing his death. According to the LA Times, Dunn thought he saw a shotgun in the SUV and fired because he felt threatened; however, no gun was found in the SUV. Jury members' disagreement over whether Dunn was guilty of first-degree murder resulted in a mistrial on that charge, though he was convicted on three counts of second-degree murder. The disagreement centered on whether Dunn's self-defense plea applied. Read what one of the Jurors had to say here.
One is reminded of the Trayvon Martin-George Zimmerman case in which Zimmerman (White and Peruvian) shot and killed Martin (Black) and was later acquitted. You can read about that case here.
Perhaps less well known is the case of Black American Marissa Alexander who fired a warning shot at her husband because she felt threatened (no one was harmed) and was subsequently sentenced to 20 years in prison. Read more about that here.
Much of the controversy revolves around "Stand Your Ground laws" and whether they excuse outright murder. To be fair, according to the LA Times, neither the Zimmerman nor Dunn legal team utilized these laws as a defense.
But there is something deeper going on here--the question of whether Black Americans are still negatively stereotyped and whether even the laws of this land are unfairly applied regarding them; in other words, whether we still have a long way to go to end racism. Clearly the answer is yes.
If anything good can come out of the Dunn case, it is a national dialogue about racism.
Some of that dialogue began Sunday when Twitter users responded to the Dunn case with poignancy using the hash tag "DangerousBlackKids," in which people posted pictures of adorable young Black and mixed-race children and young adults with sometimes humorously sarcastic messages about how stereotypically dangerous the kids in the photos are. Yet, as one Twitter respondent said, "The #dangerousblackkids tag is humanizing and important. But it's enraging that we black people STILL have to PROVE our basic humanity."
Yes, and it's also sad.
Negative stereotyping (dehumanizing) is first a psychological violence perpetrated on a perceived outsider group that ultimately leads to a more tangible violence of one sort or another. It requires educating to begin to eradicate.
Many Whites--particularly middle class and wealthy whites--live and work in environments largely segregated from meaningful interaction with other races or classes. Often stereotypes go unchallenged because people are not conscious of holding them, or are unaware that the stereotypes they hold are stereotypes, and are unaware of the violence they perpetrate by holding onto such stereotypes. This is a two-way street, though generally more dangerous for those less socially entitled.
It is regrettable that the burden of educating falls largely on those most adversely affected by this inequality, but it is always the case--just ask women's rights activists. The good news is things are changing. Not all White Americans need to be convinced Black Americans still largely have a raw deal. Many are ready and willing to challenge their own and other's preconceptions.
Here's hoping the Dunn case gives all of us the impetus to continue this dialogue and to make real advances toward a substantive equality and toward the day when no one will be considered an outsider. One thing is certain; the Dunn case is not over yet.
Maye Ralston is an opinion columnist for The Sage a blog contributor and member of the Midwest Writers Workshop Planning Committee. Her blog can be found at www.MayeRalston.net.
Photo: Sample prison doors, Some rights reserved by kIM DARam flickr photostream, The Sage nor this article endorsed, The original photo can be found here.
More Editorial Comment Stories
-
Dad Takes Care of the Radio Problem
Thursday, August 21, 2014
(SNN) - Once upon a time people listened to radios. The heart of the radio itself was a forest of diode vacuum tubes, later replaced with transistors. The tubes burned out with the rapidity of light bulbs and ...
-
Phone Call to a Friend
Wednesday, June 11, 2014
(SNN) - Yesterday I made a phone call that I did not want to make. I was afraid to make, actually. Afraid I would screw it up. I tried to talk myself out of it, in fact. But as a man of some conscience, that was ...
-
Rodger's Killing Spree: Misogyny and Entitlement
Wednesday, May 28, 2014
(SNN) - I once worked as an Employee Assistance person at a State run institution for developmentally disabled individuals where an employee complained, with righteous indignation, "They won't let me abuse the ...
-
In The Absence of Humanity
Thursday, March 20, 2014
(SNN) - I once helped a friend pack for a move only to find out, as she was leaving her apartment with the last load, that she had put her declawed cat outside and had no intention of coming back for her. What lessons ...
-
MST Survivors Vs Senate: It's Not Over Yet.
Friday, March 07, 2014
(SNN) - Senator Gillibrand's military sexual assault bill entitled the Military Justice Improvement Act (#MJIA), supported by a majority of survivors of Military Sexual Trauma (#MST), was blocked procedurally yesterday ...
-
While I am Gulping Down a Coke.
Wednesday, February 05, 2014
(SNN) - Trending earlier this week was the fallout over Coke's Super Bowl #AmericaIsBeautiful commercial, in which "America the Beautiful" was sung in several different languages--reflecting the diversity and ...
-
Fat Chance!
Thursday, January 09, 2014
(SNN) - In our society the only thing worse than a middle-aged woman is a fat middle-aged woman. No one cares how she got that way, what medical issues (or medicines) played a part, or the fact that everyone's metabolism ...
-
"Pass the MJIA"
Friday, November 29, 2013
(SNN) - In the USA thousands of military men and women are waiting for Congress to reconvene in December and, hopefully, pass the Military Justice Improvement Act of 2013 (MJIA). What the MJIA is designed to do ...
-
Target Acquired! F-Bombs Away
Sunday, September 08, 2013
(SNN) - So, this is what its come to. While hundreds of families around Alberta struggle to get their lives back together after the June flooding, the partisan feuding between our government and our official opposition ...