(SNN) - Trending earlier this week was the fallout over Coke's Super Bowl #AmericaIsBeautiful commercial, in which "America the Beautiful" was sung in several different languages--reflecting the diversity and unity of America. Watch it here.
Some were concerned about allowing one of our most sacred National songs to be sung in languages other than English, as if that somehow debased the message. Also voiced were these sentiments: English is the first language of America, and the official language of America is, and should remain, English (to sum them up).
What did these commenters forget? The first language of America was not English. It was the Algonquian language and several other Native American languages.
Native Americans, to their detriment, welcomed the first immigrants to these shores--the Vikings, the Spaniards, the French, and the English. And since the Spanish, the French, and the English settled here, people of other cultures have been welcomed, sometimes grudgingly, with the exception of Africans who were ungrudgingly brought here against their will to be slaves.
Immigrants have always been assimilated. Really. Americans are the Borg. Even conquered Native Americans were forced to learn the English language, and to adopt American dress and cultural customs.
Americans, intentionally or not, have always assimilated new cultures, expecting them to conform to the dominant culture, while blending aspects of them into the dominant cultural "organism," just as the Borg did in the Star Trek Next Generation series. And yes, I'm generalizing. In this aspect, America is no different from dominant cultures of other countries. What sets us apart is that we began with a diversity of cultures making up our country. Where do you think the term "melting-pot" came from?
What kind of English are we speaking? An English derived from many other languages that continues to evolve with each new culture we assimilate. In other words, while there may be a dominant culture in America, most exemplified by white Anglo-Saxon protestants (WASP's), even it has continued to evolve and change as a result of contact with non-dominant American cultures.
Some fear they won't be able to function if our national language is replaced with another. I, also, am only fluent in English. But what, in reality, is the likelihood of that happening? More likely, signs and forms will become multi-lingual, a process already begun, at least as far as forms and canned messages are concerned. As a friend pointed out to me, many other countries make bi-lingual street and highway signs, one example being France. Would it be so terrible if we did? Think of the extra jobs it might create--remaking all those signs. Given the enormity of that task, is it really such a big deal to have to punch a button to hear a message in one's own language?
This controversy is really about one cultural group feeling entitled to make others conform to its personal way of living, of doing things, of speaking, and of thinking. And who are the most vociferous of these? The very ones most entitled in American culture. No surprise there.
Behind the desire to make English the only language spoken and written--and sung--in America is the desire to maintain the entitled status of one cultural group. It's a refusal to accept the very real diversity of American cultures, and the equality of citizenship in which each wants to share . Yet it is this very diversity that makes America unique, strong, and gives us an edge in leadership.
We are the Borg.
Maye Ralston is an opinion columnist for The Sage and contributor to Writing Heartland blog. She is also a blog contributor and member of the Midwest Writers Workshop Planning Committee.
More Opinion News
-
Cork and the Geez Talk Oscars
Monday, February 27, 2017
The Old Coot & the Geezer analyze what went wrong and what went right at the Academy Awards this year, review the show, and recommend who should host next year. The duo are America's most respected fuddy-duddy film ...
-
Cork and the Geez Dish on the Golden Globes
Tuesday, January 24, 2017
(SNN) The Old Coot and the Geezer, affected no doubt by the rainy weather in Southern California turn grumpy as they analyze the Golden Globes and show what they mean--mostly good food for the media. Will Hollywood ...
-
Revisiting "Two-a-Days" with One Small Difference
Thursday, October 06, 2016
(SNN) For four years of high school and one in college, I would spend a couple of weeks during the dog days of August involved in what was known as "Two-a-days." Those, as any current or former football player ...
-
Coping with the Wobblies
Sunday, September 18, 2016
(SNN) Belonging to an elite group is only fun if it was one you aspired to, like giving a hundred speeches and becoming a Distinguished Toastmaster. During that time I would get the “wobblies” almost weekly. “What’s ...
-
Experimental Turkeys & Murphy's Law
Friday, September 16, 2016
(SNN) It is a paradox of science that before any breakthrough there is often a f’ed-up earlier stage. Out of this f’ed-stage have come some turkeys – turkeys that crossed the road to find something of value on the ...
-
Adventures in Eating
Sunday, August 21, 2016
(SNN) Some food combinations reside in the collective unconscious – and then there are those that shouldn’t exist at all. That special is a lottery. Visible from my apartment is a restaurant that has been struggling ...
-
No More Miscarriage Taboo
Friday, June 24, 2016
(SNN) I got a tattoo recently to honor the life and death of my daughter. The potential of her. The possibility of her. The scarred grief of her that tore up my heart. The fact that she was not born alive did not ...
-
Since the Pulse Stopped
Tuesday, June 21, 2016
Since 'the Pulse stopped,' I've been thinking a few things. (SNN) The other day 49 human beings were murdered, and 53 more were injured in an attempt to murder them, simply for being in a "Gay" nightclub called ...
-
Fall Down, Go Boom
Tuesday, March 22, 2016
(SNN) My doctor has asked me to not fall down. I’ve attempted to honor his request, but it's easier said than done. Staying upright cannot be taken for granted if, like me, you own a fused ankle, Silly Putty knee ...
-
Character Actors: Not Just In It to Win It
Friday, January 29, 2016
(SNN) The death this week of actor Abe Vigoda at 94 reminds us that there are degrees of success of Hollywood, that fame can come after thirty years of toiling in obscurity, and that a great actor is a great actor ...